In looking at even what the judges stated in the their reasons for the picks- "great background work and depth." "very nice composition." Leads me to go with my original thoughts to DQ Charly's Piece as it was not his own.  I don't think he intentionally did anything wrong, just for the purpose of this group the live tracing/ tracing/ taking a background from another piece of work is just not allowed.  Thanks for the comments guys - this happens every 30 or so battles where we learn more about what is allowed in the group.  In the past we had someone vector over someone's work in a Jessica Rabbit battle. We had someone take photos and manipulate them into their work.  This is not the place for submissions like that.  We want 100 % you for the most part.  What can you pull together (reference is fine of course but the work such as the drawing/ painting should be yours) in about a week or so.

Cheers-